Do I need another reason to hate Michel Foucault?
Surprisingly, no, but I have a new reason to hate Michel Foucault anyway!
I'm currently in a Social Control class at school, and I feel like I'm trapped in circular referencing hell. We're discussing a chapter in Foucault's 'Discipline and Power,' entitled 'the means of correct training' and in the course of the discussion, I had a question about the concept of traditional power vs. disciplinary power in reference to Jeremy Bentham's concept of the Panopticon. I genuinely wanted to clarify whether the Panopticon is an example of traditional power running concurrently with disciplinary power because of the ever present threat of punishment from above, as well as the normalizing behaviour of self-discipline caused by omnipresent surveillance.
Just a simple question of clarification. And I was not only shut down, but then trapped in an answer that was so circular, I might as well have saved myself the trouble and just found a man-sized hamster wheel to amuse/torture myself instead. The short answer was No. Because the King is dead?
What? There was a king? Umm...metaphor for the state? What??? The state as the body that can formally punish doesn't matter? Warning! Warning! Mind Overloading! Alert! Alert!
Great!! So know I'm confused even more, and Foucault has made me look like a first-class bonehead to the prof...because I don't get the circular references.
Foucault sucks. :(